bat-vs-bird-evolution-wing-development

Bat vs. Bird: Uncovering the Evolutionary Differences in Wing Development

Introduction

The diversity of bats is extraordinary. Whether climbing to access blood meals, snatching insects from leaves, or hovering to feed on tropical nectar, each behavior calls for unique wing structures. This raises intriguing questions about the evolutionary path of bats and birds.

Key Questions

• Why are there no flightless bats, akin to ostriches, foraging along riverbanks for fish?
• Why haven't bats evolved to live entirely at sea, similar to the wandering albatross?

The Interconnected Evolution of Bat Wings and Legs

The latest research suggests a key distinction: unlike birds, the evolutionary paths of bat wings and legs are closely interconnected, potentiallpy limiting their ability to exploit diverse ecological niches.

Surprising Findings

"Our initial hypothesis was that bat evolution would parallel that of birds, with wings and legs developing independently. The revelation that this is not the case was highly surprising," stated Andrew Orkney, postdoctoral researcher under Brandon Hedrick at the Department of Biomedical Sciences, College of Veterinary Medicine.

Both researchers serve as co-corresponding authors for the study published on November 1 in Nature Ecology and Evolution.

Testing the Hypothesis

Researchers have long believed that, due to the distinct functions of legs and wings, the emergence of flight in vertebrates required the independent evolution of forelimbs and hindlimbs to facilitate their adaptation to different tasks. By comparing bats and birds, this hypothesis can be tested, as both groups lack a common ancestor for flight, making them valuable independent cases for examining the evolution of flight.

Methodology

• Species Analyzed: The research team analyzed the wing and leg bones of 111 bat species and 149 bird species worldwide.
• Data Sources: Their dataset comprised X-ray images of museum specimens, along with approximately one-third of newly acquired X-rays of bat specimens housed at the Cornell University Museum of Vertebrates.

Key Findings

The researchers found that in both bats and birds, the shape of the bones within a species' wing (handwing, radius, humerus) and leg (femur and tibia) are correlated, indicating that bones within a limb evolve in concert. However, when examining the correlation between legs and wings, the findings differ: bird species exhibit species exhibit minimal to no correlation, while bats demonstrate a strong correlation.

Implications of Findings

This means that, contrary to birds, the forelimbs and hindlimbs in bats evolved in tandem: changes in wing shape, whether expanding or contracting, result a similar directional change in leg shape.

Hedrick explained, "We propose that the linked evolution of wings and legs restricts bats' ability to adapt to diverse ecological environments."

Broader Implications for Evolutionary Biology

The study's results bring new questions about the evolution of pterosaurs, an extinct lineage of flying reptiles with wings resembling those of bats.

Exploring Pterosaur Diversity

"Pterosaurs were remarkably diverse, with species ranging from tiny insectivores to colossal, giraffe-sized creatures comparable to dinosaurs," Orkney explained. "What enabled them to achieve such evolutionary success?"

Further Research Directions

After this discovery, the team began a deeper investigation into the evolutionary development of bird skeletons.

Evolutionary Success of Birds

"Our findings show that birds' wings and legs evolved separately, an important factor in their evolutionary success," Orkney explained. "However, we still don't know how birds developed this trait or when it began in their lineage."

Conclusion:

For this study, a number of measurements were conducted at the Cornell Institute of Biotechnology's imaging facility.

Source

Stay Informed: "Stay updated on the latest in evolutionary biology! Subscribe to our newsletter for insights on groundbreaking research and discoveries."