impact of generative AI on website rankings

Generative AI’s Role in Shaping Website Rankings and Traffic: What to Expect

Examine how Google's AI Overviews are impacting website traffic, along with the challenges and opportunities for maintaining online visibility.

Let us take a historical perspective. In 1901, Wilbur Wright informed his brother Orville that human flight would not be achieved for another 50 years. Remarkably, just two years later, in 1903, the Wright brothers constructed the first airplane. Similarly, the next evolution in search technology is upon us, although its full potential remains to be seen. Recently, Google announced that AI Overviews have a higher click-through rate compared to traditional web search results. Although AI Overviews are currently appearing in 15% of queries, down from a previous 84%, generative AI is already influencing website rankings and traffic and is here to stay. So, how exactly is generative AI impacting website traffic? Let us explore current insights into the effects of generative AI on website rankings and traffic. It is crucial to understand that Google and other search engines will likely continue to enhance their AI products over time. Moreover, Google’s AI Overviews are currently visible only to logged-in users with Incognito mode disabled in Chrome, indicating that these impacts may need further updates.

A decrease in organic, direct, referral, and affiliate traffic is projected

While search activity is predicted to increase, websites might experience a reduction in organic traffic. Projections include:

• AI causing a sixfold increase in daily searches.

• AI resulting in a 60% decrease in average click-through rates.

• This leading to a potential 30% reduction in organic traffic.

All websites are expected to be impacted. Gilad David Maayan, CEO of Agile SEO, studied traffic drops for 23 sites after Google AI Overview's launch, observing declines in organic traffic from 18% to 64%. 
Google's AI Overview suggests a 'winner-takes-all' dynamic, favoring larger brands over smaller ones.

There is potential for these link cards to replace featured snippets, but for now, Google has assured that featured snippets will continue to be available. This aligns with Google's history of testing featured snippets over the years. Recent changes in featured snippet rankings may have been observed.

Limited crawl budget leads to less content being indexed

Google is currently dealing with an infrastructure issue. The volume of content that requires crawling, rendering, and indexing is enormous and continues to grow with AI-generated material. The data centers are reaching their capacity, prompting Google to implement shortcuts such as reducing crawl budgets for sites with high content velocity but lower trust ratings. This implies that thin or generic content might not be indexed. With creators frequently using AI for content creation, leading to widespread spam and duplication, search engines identify such content as unoriginal. The best approach for content visibility is to provide well-crafted, experience-based content. AI lacks the ability to convey personal experiences.

CTR reductions will persist for informational query targeting

Over the years, the CTR for informational queries has shown a consistent decline. This ongoing trend has continued, marked by an unprecedented rate of decrease. Here’s an example demonstrating the significant decline in CTRs for informational queries.

During the period from December 2023 to April 2024, there was a marked 71% decrease in this website’s ranking for informational queries. Pages such as listicles, category pages, glossaries, and top-of-funnel educational content were particularly impacted. The strategic response involves a shift towards creating more transactional and navigational content, while addressing the challenge of Google favoring competing top-of-funnel queries.

Search volume growth will be mirrored by heightened fluctuations in rankings

Think back to 2016 when Google introduced mobile-first indexing, triggering considerable apprehension among SEO practitioners. Concerns surfaced about potential declines in search volume and the obsolescence of desktop devices. Yet, mobile search activity soared. Similarly, as AI becomes more pervasive, user behaviors are poised to transform. The integration of AI technologies is anticipated to fuel an expansion in search queries, thereby amplifying the variability in search result rankings.

Increased ad inventory often leads to a reduction in CPC

The placement of Google Ads above the Google AI Overview is expected to drive up Google’s revenue. Recent reports show a nearly 4% decline in Google’s ad revenue, a critical revenue source for the company. It’s logical that Google’s AI Overviews are aimed at boosting ad revenue. This strategic focus could potentially lead to lower CPC in the future. SEO professionals should work closely with PPC teams to capitalize on opportunities during potential shifts in organic traffic.

Prepare your sales team for an increase in lead quality accompanied by a probable decrease in lead quantity

Although your website’s traffic may decrease, expect an increase in high-quality search traffic. As Google suggests, 'Let Google handle the search for you.'
Google will increasingly pose questions to enhance search accuracy, aiming to deliver optimal results for each query. Google’s AI Overviews strive to enhance search experiences, simplifying user navigation to desired information. While discovery may take longer, relevant and valuable content can attract higher-quality leads to your website.

Expect an increase in user engagement on Google as they explore diverse search avenues

As ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Bing gain prominence, we anticipate a shift in how users conduct searches. Google’s AI Overviews are driving a significant change in search dynamics, with momentum building rapidly. This paradigmatic shift suggests that users may lean towards spending more time on Google or exploring other search engines. Ensure cross-network tracking pixels are operational for comprehensive data insights, and prioritize content cluster development to address complex search queries.

There is a risk exposure for product review websites

Google’s AI Overviews have had a significant impact on product reviews. With Google now generating human-like product recommendations that retain users within its platform, searchers are directed straight to stores for direct purchases. This shift is expected to result in substantial reductions in affiliate link traffic for product review sites. If you operate such a site, it’s crucial to reassess your strategy, as this trend shows no signs of abating. AI Overviews aim to enhance user experience by bypassing the intermediary role traditionally served by product review sites.

Matching intent labels with intent queries is key to refining content personalization

Organizing search queries by categories like 'solutions' and 'blogs' facilitates the AI training process to discern patterns in search intent. By harnessing learned intent capabilities, AI can tailor content to meet user needs, enhancing engagement.

Generative AI is impacting your website traffic, potentially altering it for better or worse

The ascent of AI is likely disrupting your website traffic and rankings, marked by erratic search results, ranking volatility, and limited educational resources. Facing the undeniable presence of generative AI, proactive critical thinking is essential for success. 
Embrace a mindset that prioritizes experimentation, continuous testing, and pushing boundaries beyond traditional 'best practices.' In today's landscape, basic information has become commonplace. 
Challenge yourself: How will you innovate and adapt?

Source