Skip to main content

Mozilla adviser's views on AI industry influence

Mozilla adviser's views on AI industry influence

In the AI sector, 'scaling up' has become a popular term as technology firms strive to enhance their AI capabilities by leveraging increasingly vast internet data sets.
Mozilla's Abeba Birhane, an AI expert, has long criticized the values and practices of her field, highlighting the potential global impact of its influence.
Her recent research indicates that the expansion of online data for training popular AI image-generation tools disproportionately produces racist outputs, particularly targeting Black men.
Birhane serves as a senior adviser on AI accountability at the Mozilla Foundation, the nonprofit organization behind the Firefox web browser. Originating from Ethiopia and residing in Ireland, she also holds the position of adjunct assistant professor at Trinity College Dublin.
Her discussion with The Associated Press has been shortened and clarified for conciseness.
Q: Could you share how your journey in the AI field began?
A: My academic background is in cognitive science, which doesn't typically have its own dedicated department. At my institution, cognitive science was housed within the computer science department. I found myself in a lab surrounded by machine learning researchers. While they were conducting impressive work, I noticed a lack of focus on the data itself. This struck me as both amusing and fascinating because I believe data is critical to the success of any model. I found it odd that there was little attention paid to questions like, 'What comprises my dataset?' This curiosity led me to this field, and I eventually began conducting audits of large-scale datasets.
Q: Could you elaborate on your research concerning the ethical principles underlying artificial intelligence?
A: There are diverse perspectives on machine learning's nature. While AI practitioners often view it as a purely mathematical and neutral field, social scientists argue that, like any technology, it reflects the values of its developers. To investigate this, we conducted a comprehensive analysis of the top hundred influential machine learning papers to rigorously understand the field's core concerns.
Q: One of the core values identified was the emphasis on scaling up.
A: Scale is often regarded as the ultimate benchmark for success, with prominent researchers from leading firms such as DeepMind, Google and Meta asserting that increasing scale mitigates noise and balances inconsistencies. The premise is that as datasets expand, they should stabilize, approximating a normal distribution or aligning more closely with the actual truth.
Q: Your research has investigated the negative implications of scaling up. What are some of the adverse effects identified?
A: Our research indicates that as datasets are scaled, so too does the prevalence of harmful content such as hate speech and toxicity. Specifically, we observed a significant increase in hateful content when datasets were expanded form 400 million to 2 billion entries. This finding challenges the notion that scaling datasets simply balances out biases and inaccuracies. Additionally, our analysis revealed a disproportionate allocation of suspicious or criminal labels to darker-skinned individuals, particularly women.
Q: How hopeful are you about the AI field embracing the modifications you have recommended?
A: The impact of these outputs is not confined to mathematical and technical aspects; they also play a crucial role in shaping societal norms and influences. Our recommendations advocate for the incorporation of values like justice, fairness and privacy into AI systems. Nevertheless, I am profoundly skeptical that the industry will embrace these suggestions. The industry's track record shows a tendency to overlook societal concerns unless compelled by legal requirements or substantial public pressure that could damage their reputation.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

NASA chile scientists comet 3i atlas nickel mystery

NASA and Chilean Scientists Study 3I/ATLAS, A Comet That Breaks the Rules Interstellar visitors are rare guests in our Solar System , but when they appear they often rewrite the rules of astronomy. Such is the case with 3I/ATLAS , a fast-moving object that has left scientists puzzled with its bizarre behaviour. Recent findings from NASA and Chilean researchers reveal that this comet-like body is expelling an unusual plume of nickel — without the iron that typically accompanies it. The discovery challenges conventional wisdom about how comets form and evolve, sparking both excitement and controversy across the scientific community. A Cosmic Outsider: What Is 3I/ATLAS? The object 3I/ATLAS —the third known interstellar traveler after "Oumuamua (2017) and 2I/Borisov (2019) —was first detected in July 2025 by the ATLAS telescope network , which scans he skies for potentially hazardous objects. Earlier images from Chile's Vera C. Rubin Observatory had unknowingly captured it, but ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Quantum neural algorithms for creating illusions

Quantum Neural Networks and Optical Illusions: A New Era for AI? Introduction At first glance, optical illusions, quantum mechanics, and neural networks may appear unrelated. However, my recent research in APL Machine Learning Leverages "quantum tunneling" to create a neural network that perceives optical illusions similarly to humans. Neural Network Performance The neural network I developed successfully replicated human perception of the Necker cube and Rubin's vase illusions, surpassing the performance of several larger, conventional neural networks in computer vision tasks. This study may offer new perspectives on the potential for AI systems to approximate human cognitive processes. Why Focus on Optical Illusions? Understanding Visual Perception O ptical illusions mani pulate our visual  perce ption,  presenting scenarios that may or may not align with reality. Investigating these illusions  provides valuable understanding of brain function and dysfunction, inc...
Post a Comment
Read more

fractal universe cosmic structure mandelbrot

Is the Universe a Fractal? Unraveling the Patterns of Nature The Cosmic Debate: Is the Universe a Fractal? For decades, cosmologists have debated whether the universe's large-scale structure exhibits fractal characteristics — appearing identical across scales. The answer is nuanced: not entirely, but in certain res pects, yes. It's a com plex matter. The Vast Universe and Its Hierarchical Structure Our universe is incredibly vast, com prising a p proximately 2 trillion galaxies. These galaxies are not distributed randomly but are organized into hierarchical structures. Small grou ps ty pically consist of u p to a dozen galaxies. Larger clusters contain thousands, while immense su perclusters extend for millions of light-years, forming intricate cosmic  patterns. Is this where the story comes to an end? Benoit Mandelbrot and the Introduction of Fractals During the mid-20th century, Benoit Mandelbrot introduced fractals to a wider audience . While he did not invent the conce pt —...
Post a Comment
Read more