Why are humanoid robots not common in households?

Humanoids: The Robots We've Long Anticipated--What's Delaying Their Arrival in Our Homes?

The dream of humanoid robots, akin to characters like C3PO from "Star Wars," has fascinated us for decades. Today, companies like Tesla are integrating Artificial Intelligence (AI) into robotic designs, yet significant technical and safety challenges continue to hinder progress. Despite these obstacles, the vision of versatile household robots remains alive, driving ongoing innovation in the field of robotics.

The Evolution of Humanoid Robotics

In 2013, Boston Dynamics introduced Atlas, a 6-foot-2 humanoid robot, during the DARPA Robotics Challenge. Atlas showcased remarkable capabilities, such as walking on uneven terrain, jumping off platforms, and climbing stairs. This unveiling felt like a turning point, suggesting a future where robots could assist with daily tasks, potentially alleviating the burdens of elder care and household chores.

Since then, advancements in AI--particularly in computer vision and machine learning--have accelerated. The rise of large language models and generative AI has opened new avenues for human-computer interaction. However, in practice, physical robots are still largely limited to industrial environments, performing specialized tasks behind safety barriers. In our homes, robots remain restricted to vacuum cleaners and lawnmowers, far from the multifunctional "Rosie the Robot" we envisioned.

Jenny Read, director of the robotics program at the UK's Advanced Research and Invention Agency (Aria), notes that "the physical development of robotic bodies has progressed minimally since the 1950s." The disparity between rapid software evolution and slower hardware development highlights the challenges facing the industry. Nathan Lepora, a Professor of Robotics and AI at Bristol University, explains that "developing a robot demands far more resources. While creating algorithms is relatively straightforward, building a robot requires significant physical hardware, which makes the process much slower."

Current Development and Future Prospects

Despite these challenges, research laboratories and companies are actively working to bridge the gap between AI capabilities and physical robotics. Several humanoid robots are currently under development, with some nearing commercialization. Boston Dynamics has phased out its original hydraulic Atlas model and introduced an electric version slated for testing in Hyundai factories next year. Oregon-based Agility Robotics claims its Digit robot is the first humanoid employed in a paid position, transporting boxes in a logistics facility. Furthermore, Elon Musk has asserted that Tesla's humanoid robot, known as Optimus, will be operational in car factories by next year.

However, we are sitll far from achieving robots that can operate effectively outside controlled environments. Read emphasizes that "AI advancements can only go so far with existing hardware," highlighting that many tasks heavily depend on a robot's physical capabilities. While generative AI can create poetry or generate images, it cannot perform the complex, dangerous tasks we hope to automate. For such applications, physical dexterity is crucial.

The Challenge of Robotic Dexterity

A successful robot design often begins with the concept of hands. Read states, "The effectiveness of many robotic applications relies heavily on the ability to handle objects with accuracy and finesse." Humans naturally adapt to a variety of tasks---lifting weights or managing delicate items---due to our exceptional tactile perception.

In contrast, robots struggle with these tasks. Read's Aria initiative, backed by £57 million in funding, aims to address limitations in robotic dexterity. Rich Walker, director of Shadow Robot in London, identifies scale as a significant hurdle. The Shadow Dexterous Hand, designed to mimic a human hand, features four fingers and a thumb but is connected to a larger robotic arm filled with electronics. "It's a packing issue," Walker explains.

Shadow Robot's latest innovation, DEX-EE, features three thumb-like digits equipped with tactile sensors, developed in collaboration with Google DeepMind. This design aims to enable the robot hand to learn object manipulation through reinforcement learning. However, traditional robot hands often sustain damage from collisions, complicating their functionality.

To address training challenges, DeepMind recently introduced DemoStart, a new training method that uses simulations to prepare robots for real-world tasks. While this approach can significantly reduce costs and time, the transfer of skills from simulation to physical execution is not always perfect.

The Future of Humanoids

While hands are essential, they represent just one part of the whole. Companies and research institutions are developing fully realized humanoid robots, with the attraction to humanoids possibly rooted in psychological factors. Walker notes, "It's the robot we've all been anticipating---it resembles C3PO." There's also a practical rationale for using a human form: our environments are designed with people in mind.

However, humanoid designs aren't optimal for every situation. Wheeled robots can navigate spaces effectively, while four-legged robots often outperform bipeds in challenging terrains. Boston Dynamic's Spot robot can traverse rough surfaces and right itself after falls, something two-legged robots often struggle with.

As humanoid robots evolve, ensuring safety during their transition from laboratories to public spaces is paramount. The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) has established a study group to develop standards for humanoid robots, addressing the different challenges they pose in shared environments.

Most roboticists agree that a versatile home robot capable of performing a range of tasks is still a distant goal. A representative from Boston Dynamics asserts, "While we have entered the era of functional humanoids, the journey towards a truly general-purpose humanoid robot will be lengthy and challenging."

In conclusion, while significant strides have been made toward creating humanoid robots, many challenges remain. The dream of a fully functional household robot may still be on the horizon, but ongoing research and development continue to push the boundaries of what is possible. As we look to the future, the collaboration between AI advancements and robotics may one day bring us closer to the humanoid companions we have long imagined.

Source